| Ataenius lucanus Horn, 1871 |
| Ataenius nocturnus Nomura, 1943 |
| Ataenius nugator Harold, 1880 |
| Ataenius nunenmacheri Cartwright, 1974 |
| Ataenius oaxacaensis Stebnicka & Lago, 2005 |
| Ataenius opatrinus Harold, 1867 |
| Ataenius parkeri Cartwright, 1974 |
| Ataenius perforatus Harold, 1867 |
| Ataenius picinus Harold, 1867 |
| Ataenius platensis Blanchard, 1846 |
| Ataenius polyglyptus Bates, 1887 |
| Ataenius pseudousingeri Galante, Stebnicka & Verdú, 2003 |
| Ataenius puncticollis LeConte, 1858 |
| Ataenius punctifrons Cartwright, 1974 |
| Ataenius rhyticephalus (Chevrolat, 1864) |
| Ataenius rickardasi Hinton, 1938 |
| Ataenius rugopygus Cartwright, 1974 |
| Ataenius sabinoi Cartwright, 1974 |
| Ataenius scalptifrons Bates, 1887 |
| Ataenius sculptor Harold, 1868 |