| Aphodius amplinotum Gordon & Howden, 1973 |
| Aphodius azellus A. Schmidt, 1907 |
| Aphodius aztecus Harold, 1863 |
| Aphodius barrerai Islas, 1955 |
| Aphodius bifrons Bates, 1887 |
| Aphodius burgosi Deloya & McCarty, 1992 |
| Aphodius caballeroi Islas, 1945 |
| Aphodius charmionus Bates, 1887 |
| Aphodius coloradensis Horn, 1870 |
| Aphodius constricollis Bates, 1889 |
| Aphodius coronadoi Islas, 1955 |
| Aphodius cruentatus LeConte, 1878 |
| Aphodius cuniculus Chevrolat, 1864 |
| Aphodius diminutus Bates, 1887 |
| Aphodius dugesi Bates, 1887 |
| Aphodius duplex Bates, 1887 |
| Aphodius durangoi Gordon & Cartwright, 1973 |
| Aphodius epulus Gordon & Cartwright, 1973 |
| Aphodius fimetarius (Linnaeus, 1758) |
| Aphodius fuliginosus Harold, 1863 |