| Eugenia capuli var. capuli (Schltdl. & Cham.) Hook. & Arn., 1841 |
| Eugenia capuli var. lindeniana (O. Berg) Lundell, 1965 |
| Eugenia capulioides Lundell, 1942 |
| Eugenia carranzae Lundell, 1968 |
| Eugenia caryophyllata Thunb., 1788 |
| Eugenia ceibensis Standl., 1940 |
| Eugenia cerrocacaoensis Barrie, 2005 |
| Eugenia chiapensis Lundell, 1938 |
| Eugenia chinajensis Standl. & Steyerm., 1944 |
| Eugenia choapamensis Standl., 1940 |
| Eugenia citroides Lundell, 1942 |
| Eugenia cocquericotensis Lundell, 1937 |
| Eugenia coetzalensis Durán-Esp. & Cast.-Campos, 2018 |
| Eugenia colipensis O. Berg, 1858 |
| Eugenia comitanensis Lundell, 1961 |
| Eugenia conglobata Sessé & Moc., 1888 |
| Eugenia contrerasii Lundell, 1961 |
| Eugenia conzattii Standl., 1924 |
| Eugenia crenularis Lundell, 1961 |
| Eugenia culminicola McVaugh, 1963 |