| Eugenia pimenta var. longifolia (Sims) DC., 1828 |
| Eugenia pimenta var. ovalifolia DC., 1828 |
| Eugenia pleurocarpa Standl., 1929 |
| Eugenia praeterita McVaugh, 1963 |
| Eugenia principium McVaugh, 1963 |
| Eugenia pueblana Lundell, 1961 |
| Eugenia purpusii Standl., 1926 |
| Eugenia pusilana Lundell, 1980 |
| Eugenia queretaroana Sánchez-Cháv.& Zamudio, 2016 |
| Eugenia ravenii Lundell, 1968 |
| Eugenia rekoi Standl., 1924 |
| Eugenia rhombea (O. Berg) Krug & Urb., 1895 |
| Eugenia rinconiensis Mattos, 2005 |
| Eugenia riograndis Lundell, 1945 |
| Eugenia rubella Lundell, 1961 |
| Eugenia salamensis Donn. Sm., 1899 |
| Eugenia sarahchazaroi Cházaro, Franc. Gut.& J.R. Carral, 2023 |
| Eugenia savannarum Standl. & Steyerm., 1944 |
| Eugenia schiedeana Schltdl., 1839 |
| Eugenia sibunensis Lundell, 1942 |