| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) difformis LeConte, 1847 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) flohri Nevinson, 1892 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) furiosus Bates, 1889 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) furiosus subsp. furiosus Bates, 1889 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) furiosus subsp. psuedofurcosus Balthasar, 1939 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) melampus Harold, 1863 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) nimrod Harold, 1863 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) quadridens (Say, 1835) |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) quadridens subsp. borealis Olsoufieff, 1924 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) quadridens subsp. quadridens (Say, 1835) |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) sallei Harold, 1863 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) vindex MacLeay, 1819 |
| Phanaeus (Phanaeus) yecoraensis Edmonds, 2004 |
| Phanaeus amethystinus Harold, 1863 |
| Phanaeus amethystinus subsp. amethystinus Harold, 1863 |
| Phanaeus blackalleri Delgado, 1991 |
| Phanaeus endymion Harold, 1863 |
| Phanaeus florhi Nevinson, 1892 |
| Phanaeus guatemalensis Harold, 1871 |
| Phanaeus mexicanus Harold, 1863 |